St. Paul United Church of Christ has a rich tradition of music and talented musicians in the church. Music plays a key role in the worship service and is supported by a Chancel Choir directed by Daniel Landis. The choir usually presents an anthem and also leads congregational singing. Members of the choir often provide solos. During holidays and special occasions the choir presents cantatas and special music.
The St. Paul Bell choir has performed with the Lima Symphony Orchestra on two occasions. The choir is directed by Wendy Schlenker and the bell choir has five octaves of bells and has duplicate bells for several octaves which give the choir a very rich and full sound. The bell choir usually performs once each month and provide special music on religious holidays.